A judge in Michigan is questioning the decision to transfer two men convicted of playing secondary roles in a plot to kidnap Governor Gretchen Whitmer to out-of-state federal prisons. Paul Bellar and Joe Morrison have the right to appeal their convictions after a trial on state charges in Jackson County in 2022. However, their lawyers argue that the distance makes it extremely difficult to work with their clients, interfering with their right to access Michigan courts.
The transfer of Bellar and Morrison to federal prisons in Pennsylvania and Illinois, respectively, has raised concerns among their legal representatives. Michael Faraone, who represents Morrison, described the move as “mind-boggling” and “appalling.” He emphasized that the men are not affiliated with a terrorist organization like al-Qaida.
Bellar, Morrison, and Pete Musico were found guilty of providing material support for a terrorist act and other charges. While they did not have a direct role in the kidnapping conspiracy, they had undergone gun training with the group’s leader, Adam Fox, and shared his animosity towards Governor Whitmer, law enforcement, and public officials, particularly due to COVID-19 restrictions.
Musico has been sentenced to at least 12 years in prison, Morrison received 10 years, and Bellar was given a seven-year sentence. Morrison was transferred to a federal prison in Illinois, while Bellar was sent to Pennsylvania. Musico is currently in West Virginia but has not formally challenged his placement like the other two men.
The defense lawyers argue that the Michigan Department of Corrections (MDOC) had no legal authority to transfer Morrison out of state. Ron Ambrose, an appellate lawyer, highlighted the difficulties in communicating with Bellar, as trial transcripts sent through mail have been returned.
Assistant Attorney General John Pallas stated that he did not have specific information regarding the reasons for the out-of-state transfers, but cited “general safety concerns.” Judge Thomas Wilson expressed the need for clarification, stating that without such information, it feels like they are “flying blind.”
The Michigan Department of Corrections has not responded to requests for comment. Pallas promised to assist the lawyers in improving their ability to communicate with their clients. Judge Wilson scheduled a hearing for December 1 to obtain answers and an update on the situation.
