Former Michigan State University football coach Mel Tucker’s attorneys have filed a motion to dismiss Brenda Tracy’s lawsuit regarding the release of personal text messages. This motion comes after both parties agreed to a protective order limiting the release of information from a cellphone owned by Tracy’s deceased friend and former employee. Tucker’s attorneys argue that the protective order resolves Tracy’s concerns and that her legal claims in the lawsuit are without merit. Tucker’s attorney, Andrew Abood, declined to comment on the matter. Tracy’s attorney, Eric Delaporte, responded to an email seeking comment by stating that he is not concerned and will provide a response in December.
The legal dispute over the text messages began after USA Today published an article about a sexual harassment investigation involving Tucker. The university suspended Tucker without pay and later fired him for cause. On the day of a key hearing in the harassment case, Tucker’s legal team released text messages between Tracy and Ahlan Alvarado. These messages were meant to show that Tracy had a consensual personal relationship with Tucker. Tracy sought a court order to prevent the release of further messages, citing sensitive and confidential information that could cause harm.
A stipulated protective order was entered on October 26, which prevents the release of health information and the identification of sexual assault survivors or individuals involved in romantic or sexual relationships with Tracy or Tucker. Tucker, who denies any wrongdoing and claims a consensual relationship with Tracy, plans to file a lawsuit over his termination, as his contract entitles him to about $80 million in guaranteed money. A hearing to dismiss Tracy’s complaint has been scheduled for early January.
Overall, the legal battle over the text messages continues as both parties present their arguments in court.
